How cost segregation, excess basis, and strategic 1031 Exchange planning could create additional tax advantages for commercial real estate investors.
If you’ve been following my blogs, watching my YouTube channel, or have heard me speak about the benefits of a 1031 Exchange, you already know that I spend a great deal of time discussing planning, leverage, and building long-term wealth through investment real estate.
Well, Uncle Sam has given us another reason to take a closer look at how we structure our real estate investments.
And this one could be significant!
In July 2025, the federal government enacted the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, restoring 100% bonus depreciation for eligible property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025.
Unlike the previous phase-down schedule, the new legislation makes the 100% deduction permanent under current federal law.
That’s potentially great news for commercial real estate investors.
But what does 100% bonus depreciation mean for a 1031 Exchange?
More importantly, can investors combine the tax-deferral benefits of a 1031 Exchange with accelerated depreciation to create an even greater tax advantage?
The answer is potentially yes. But there are important rules every investor should understand before completing an exchange.
Let’s take a closer look.
What Is Cost Segregation in Commercial Real Estate?
Most commercial real estate investors are familiar with depreciation. It’s one of the significant tax advantages of owning investment property.
Generally, the IRS allows the depreciable portion of a commercial building to be written off over 39 years. Residential rental buildings are typically depreciated over 27.5 years.
That’s a long time to recover the cost of your investment through depreciation deductions.
But here’s something many investors don’t realize.
Not everything associated with a commercial property must be depreciated over 39 years.
Certain improvements and building components may qualify for substantially shorter depreciation schedules.
For example, depending on their specific use and classification:
- 5-year or 7-year property: Certain flooring, cabinetry, and specialized electrical systems.
- 15-year property: Parking lots, sidewalks, landscaping, and exterior site lighting.
- 39-year property: The remaining commercial building structure.
This is where a cost segregation study becomes valuable.
A cost segregation study is a detailed engineering-based and tax analysis that identifies portions of a property qualifying for shorter depreciation periods.
Instead of depreciating everything together over several decades, qualifying components are separated and assigned to their appropriate depreciation categories.
With the restoration of 100% bonus depreciation, certain qualifying assets with recovery periods of 20 years or less may be eligible for an immediate federal deduction in the year they’re placed in service.
Think about that for a moment.
An investor who otherwise might have waited five, seven, or fifteen years to fully depreciate certain improvements could potentially deduct their entire eligible cost in the first year.
That’s a meaningful opportunity.
For additional information, review the IRS guidance on depreciation.
How Does 100% Bonus Depreciation Work With a 1031 Exchange?
Here’s where your 1031 Exchange changes the equation.
When purchasing investment real estate outright, the concept of cost segregation may be relatively straightforward.
However, when acquiring replacement property through a tax-deferred 1031 Exchange, there’s an additional consideration that investors frequently overlook.
Not every dollar of your replacement property’s value represents new depreciable basis eligible for 100% bonus depreciation.
Let me explain.
When you complete a 1031 Exchange, the tax basis in your replacement property generally consists of two components.
1. Carryover Basis (Exchanged Basis)
Your carryover basis represents the adjusted tax basis carried over from your relinquished property, also known as your Downleg.
Generally, this portion continues under the applicable depreciation rules rather than receiving an entirely new depreciation schedule.
2. Excess Basis
Your excess basis generally represents additional tax basis created when you invest more into your replacement property than the value of the property you relinquished, assuming a fully deferred exchange without other basis adjustments.
This additional basis can create an opportunity for new bonus depreciation.
Under the applicable tax regulations, bonus depreciation in a like-kind exchange generally applies to qualifying excess basis, while special rules govern the carryover basis.
In other words, completing a 1031 Exchange does not automatically create a brand-new depreciation deduction on the entire value of your replacement property.
Understanding the difference between carryover basis and excess basis can significantly affect how you evaluate your next investment.
1031 Exchange and Bonus Depreciation: A $4 Million Investment Example
Let’s put some real numbers to this strategy.
Suppose you’ve owned a commercial investment property for many years. You’ve enjoyed rental income, watched the property appreciate, and built substantial equity.
Now you’re ready to sell and exchange into another investment property.
Your Relinquished Property (Downleg)
| Financial Detail | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sales price | $3,000,000 |
| Existing loan | $1,000,000 |
| Net equity | $2,000,000 |
| Adjusted tax basis | $800,000 |
| Illustrative realized gain | $2,200,000 |
This simplified example assumes no selling expenses or other basis adjustments.
Without a 1031 Exchange, that $2.2 million gain could create a substantial federal and state tax liability, depending on your individual circumstances.
Instead, you complete a tax-deferred 1031 Exchange and purchase a replacement property for $4 million.
You use your $2 million in exchange proceeds and obtain a new loan for the remaining $2 million.
Notice what you’ve accomplished.
You’ve sold a $3 million property and purchased a $4 million property, preserving your equity while increasing the value of your real estate investment by $1 million.
Your Replacement Property (Upleg)
| Financial Detail | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | $4,000,000 |
| Deferred gain | $2,200,000 |
| Total replacement property tax basis | $1,800,000 |
| Carryover basis | $800,000 |
| Excess basis | $1,000,000 |
That $1 million in excess basis is where things become particularly interesting.
Suppose a properly prepared cost segregation study determines that, after accounting for nondepreciable land and allocating basis among the improvements, $200,000 of the excess basis is attributable to qualifying 5-year, 7-year, and 15-year property.
Under current federal bonus depreciation rules, you could potentially deduct that entire $200,000 in the first year those qualifying assets are placed in service.
Potential first-year federal depreciation deduction: $200,000
And remember, this opportunity may exist while you’re also deferring recognition of your $2.2 million gain through your 1031 Exchange.
That’s a pretty compelling combination!
Of course, every investor’s tax situation is different. Your CPA must evaluate the exact basis allocation, depreciation eligibility, and whether you can currently use those deductions.
Why Trading Up Through a 1031 Exchange Can Create More Tax Advantages
There’s a reason I spend so much time educating investors about the advantages of trading up into larger investment properties.
When structured properly, a 1031 Exchange can allow you to preserve equity, acquire a more valuable asset, and potentially generate additional income.
With 100% bonus depreciation available, increasing the value of your replacement property could also create additional depreciation opportunities.
Consider the difference:
- Exchange into a $3 million property: Assuming a fully deferred exchange and no other adjustments, you generally create little or no excess basis.
- Exchange into a $4 million property: You may create approximately $1 million in excess basis.
- Exchange into a $5 million property: You may create approximately $2 million in excess basis.
Some portion of that excess basis may qualify for accelerated depreciation, depending on the property’s components and applicable tax rules.
Here’s another important point.
You do not necessarily have to replace debt with debt to complete a fully tax-deferred 1031 Exchange.
I’ve discussed this common misconception in previous articles.
The objective is generally to acquire replacement property of equal or greater value and reinvest the necessary equity while avoiding taxable boot.
New financing, additional cash, or a combination of both can help accomplish that objective.
In our example, whether the additional $1 million in property value is funded through borrowing or new cash, that additional investment may help create excess basis.
This is why I continually remind investors that a 1031 Exchange isn’t simply a tax strategy.
It’s an investment strategy.
5 Important Considerations Before Combining Bonus Depreciation and a 1031 Exchange
Before anyone gets too excited, I want to make something clear.
Bonus depreciation is not a magical way to eliminate taxes.
It can accelerate deductions and potentially improve near-term cash flow, but it also comes with important considerations.
1. Depreciation Recapture Does Not Disappear
When you eventually sell a property in a taxable transaction, previously claimed depreciation can affect the amount and character of your taxable gain.
Certain accelerated depreciation deductions may produce ordinary-income recapture.
If your relinquished property previously benefited from a cost segregation study, additional recapture issues may also arise during your next exchange.
In some circumstances, recapture rules can trigger taxable income even when other portions of the transaction qualify for 1031 deferral.
That’s why your CPA needs to evaluate both the Downleg and the Upleg, not simply the replacement property you’re purchasing.
Remember, we’re generally talking about tax deferral, not automatic tax elimination.
2. A Depreciation Deduction Does Not Always Mean Immediate Tax Savings
Many rental real estate investments are considered passive activities under federal tax law.
That means your ability to use a substantial depreciation deduction may be limited by passive activity loss rules and other restrictions.
For some investors, deductions may offset passive income.
Others may need to carry certain losses into future years.
Simply generating a $200,000 depreciation deduction doesn’t automatically mean you’ll receive an immediate tax benefit from the entire amount.
Your CPA should evaluate how that deduction fits into your overall tax situation.
You can learn more through the IRS Passive Activity and At-Risk Rules.
3. California Investors Face Different Depreciation Rules
For those of us here in California, there’s an additional consideration.
California generally does not conform to federal bonus depreciation provisions.
That means an investor could have one depreciation calculation for their federal income tax return and a substantially different calculation for their California return.
California isn’t the only state with its own depreciation rules.
Before assuming a federal depreciation deduction will produce the same state tax benefit, have your CPA evaluate the applicable state requirements.
4. Not Every Commercial Property Offers the Same Depreciation Opportunities
This is particularly important for investors considering Absolute Net Single Tenant properties.
Many of my clients sell properties requiring active management and exchange into investments designed to provide a more passive ownership experience.
Those properties can be excellent replacement candidates.
However, their depreciation opportunities can vary considerably.
For example, if you’re purchasing a ground-leased property where you own only the land, there may be little or no depreciable property to evaluate.
Land itself is not depreciable.
On the other hand, if you’re acquiring both the land and improvements under an Absolute Net Single Tenant lease, certain components may present cost segregation opportunities.
These could include parking areas, exterior improvements, and qualifying building components.
It depends on what you’re purchasing and how those assets are classified.
And please, don’t select replacement property simply because of a potential depreciation deduction.
The quality of the real estate, tenant strength, lease structure, location, and long-term investment objectives should remain primary considerations.
5. Make Sure a Cost Segregation Study Is Worth the Expense
Cost segregation studies aren’t free.
A qualified professional must evaluate the improvements, classify the appropriate components, and provide documentation supporting the depreciation allocations.
For a larger commercial property, the potential tax benefit might justify the cost.
But what about a smaller property with very little excess basis?
The numbers might not work.
That’s why requesting a preliminary cost segregation assessment before committing to a comprehensive study can be worthwhile.
Although a formal study can often be completed after closing, and in some circumstances in a subsequent tax year through appropriate accounting procedures, evaluating the potential benefits early can help guide your investment decisions.
Why 1031 Exchange Planning Should Begin Before You Sell
If there’s one message I hope you’ve taken away from my articles and videos, it’s this:
The success of a tax-deferred 1031 Exchange starts long before your relinquished property closes escrow.
Far too many investors wait until their property is in escrow, or worse, until it has already closed, before seriously considering replacement options.
By then, the clock is running.
You generally have:
- 45 calendar days to identify your replacement property.
- 180 calendar days to complete your exchange, subject to the applicable tax-return filing deadline.
Now imagine trying to evaluate replacement property, financing, depreciation opportunities, passive loss limitations, and potential recapture issues while navigating those deadlines.
That’s a great deal of pressure that could have been avoided through advance planning.
When I work with an investor considering a 1031 Exchange, my objective is to begin the planning process as early as possible.
That means coordinating with the investor’s CPA, Qualified Intermediary, and other professional advisors while identifying potential replacement properties that meet their financial objectives.
A cost segregation analysis may be one more consideration worth incorporating into that process.
Not every investor will benefit, and not every replacement property will qualify for substantial deductions.
But you certainly want to understand the opportunity before making your investment decision.
After all, why discover a potentially significant tax advantage after you’ve already committed to the wrong replacement property?
Frequently Asked Questions About Bonus Depreciation and 1031 Exchanges
Can you claim 100% bonus depreciation on a 1031 Exchange replacement property?
Potentially, yes. Qualifying components of the replacement property’s excess basis may be eligible for 100% bonus depreciation under current federal law. Carryover basis is subject to different depreciation rules.
What is excess basis in a 1031 Exchange?
Excess basis generally refers to additional tax basis created when an investor acquires replacement property of greater value than the relinquished property, subject to applicable adjustments. This additional basis may create new depreciation opportunities.
Does a cost segregation study help with a 1031 Exchange?
A cost segregation study can identify qualifying property components eligible for shorter depreciation periods. When combined with a properly structured 1031 Exchange, it may help investors accelerate certain depreciation deductions.
Does 100% bonus depreciation eliminate capital gains taxes?
No. Bonus depreciation accelerates eligible deductions but does not automatically eliminate capital gains taxes or depreciation recapture. The actual tax benefits depend on the investor’s circumstances and applicable rules.
Is 100% bonus depreciation available in California?
California generally does not conform to federal bonus depreciation rules. Investors should consult their CPA to understand the differences between federal and California depreciation treatment.
Final Thoughts: A 1031 Exchange Is About More Than Deferring Taxes
The restoration of permanent 100% bonus depreciation gives commercial real estate investors another potential tool for building and preserving wealth.
When combined with a properly structured 1031 Exchange, cost segregation, and thoughtful replacement property selection, that tool can become particularly valuable.
But remember, the tax benefits should complement your investment strategy, not dictate it.
A successful exchange begins with education, improves with proper planning, and ultimately depends on assembling the right team of professionals.
That’s what I advocate, and it’s why I created Best1031Online.com.
The more you understand your options before selling, the better positioned you’ll be to make informed decisions about your financial future.
Plan First. Exchange Wisely. Build Wealth.
We Are Here to Help
Interested in discussing your next 1031 Exchange?
If you’re an investment property owner considering the sale of a long-held asset and would like to discuss how a properly planned 1031 Exchange might help you preserve equity, defer taxes, and transition into a different investment property, I welcome the opportunity to speak with you.
Visit Best1031Online.com for a private, no-obligation consultation.
James Bean
SVN – Rich Investment Real Estate Partners
CA DRE #01970580
Phone: 805-779-1031
Email: james.bean@svn.com
For real estate agents and brokers: If you’re representing an investment property owner who may benefit from a 1031 Exchange, visit my website and select the Agent’s button to learn how we can work together to better serve your client.
Stay Connected With Best 1031 Online
Subscribe to my YouTube channel, Best 1031 Online, for educational videos and monthly episodes of QI Corner.
You can also follow me on LinkedIn, X, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook at @1031BrokerJames.
Disclaimer: This article is provided for general educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or investment advice. Tax laws, eligibility requirements, and individual circumstances vary. All investors should consult their CPA, tax attorney, and other qualified professional advisors before implementing a 1031 Exchange, cost segregation study, or depreciation strategy.
